Commentary on certain Japanese blades

Open to public view.

Commentary on certain Japanese blades

Postby MEversbergII » 03 Feb 2014 17:12

So I've noticed over the years that I have seen considerably more "the [iconic Japanese sword] is NOT the best thing ever!" media (videos and texts) than anything that directly asserts that "the [iconic Japanese sword] totally IS the best thing ever!".

That is to say I have seen things that have said "Ah, the [iconic Japanese sword] is superior to the [not], because of [some thing]!" But it is far and away outnumbered by works to the contrary. Additionally, a majority of what I've seen in favor of the [iconic Japanese sword] is rather a bit more subtle than a crass "It's simply better because of X". Maybe a more favorable stat profile in a given game (sometimes justified by the weapon in question actually being better than the standard either due to magic or actually having some kind of above and beyond property).

The only one I can think of that talks about the [iconic Japanese weapon] being overtly better is a short clip wherein it was tested against a "Medieval Braodsword" at the Royal Armoury (we all know the clip, but I don't know what the whole documentary was about). Most documentaries about the sword in question just kind of talk about it in it's own context - Secrets of the Samurai Sword comes to mind.

This could be because of the swordly company I keep. I've been much more entwined with the WMA/European Medieval(ish) History and haven't really seen how the "other half" lives.

Just an observation.

When I was a fighting-man, the kettle-drums they beat,
The people scattered gold-dust before my horses feet;
But now I am a great king, the people hound my track
With poison in my wine-cup, and daggers at my back.

Best Advice on the Whole Site
User avatar
Posts: 876
Joined: 26 Oct 2012 06:00
Location: Lexington Park, Maryland

Re: Commentary on certain Japanese blades

Postby demoman_chaos » 14 Feb 2014 20:35

There are still a LOT of Japanese sword fanatics out there, and they love to spill their dribble. I suspect the more fanatic they are, the less they know about the other types of Japanese swords beyond that one in particular.

However, there is also a growing portion of people who study other sword arts (HEMA for example) and so the media to the contrary has been growing significantly. Do debunking of the myth that Japanese swords are better is a fairly easy topic and because of the sword in question is likely to gain a lot of views and comments from people who won't have their mind changed even with a matter rearrangement ray.
User avatar
Posts: 16
Joined: 22 Sep 2013 15:49
Location: A chair by a computer

Re: Commentary on certain Japanese blades

Postby Gordon H » 15 Feb 2014 11:34

This is an area where I can be fairly neutral as I did JSA for just over 15 years and I now do HEMA.

But Matt did a fairly good set of videos which pretty much sums up everything! ... cnSnAc2kHV
"You is filth, you is scum, but I will make you soldiers"

-Sharpe's Regiment

Ego ridebo sicut mundus urit
User avatar
Gordon H
Staff Sergeant
Posts: 168
Joined: 12 Apr 2012 17:34
Location: The Peoples Republic

Return to General Historical Martial Arts

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 14 guests